U-Haul is the one major chain that publishes a live per-gallon refill price: its propane results pages list each location with its own current price. Each price above was read on that page on Oct 30, 2026 and carries its source link and check date. U-Haul prices are live and change — a verified price here is shown fresh for 30 days, visibly aged after that, and demoted to “last reported” after 90 days (see the methodology). Confirm the current price before you drive.
Propane refill in the New York metro area
New York has 3 verified refill prices, every one read from U-Haul's own propane results pages on Oct 30, 2026. The lowest is U-Haul Moving & Storage of Jersey City in Jersey City, NJ at $4.25/gal (+ tax).
These are New York metro-area stations, not stations inside New York City. No U-Haul refill station inside NYC proper appeared in U-Haul's results for a New York search. The stations below are the nearest suburban locations U-Haul itself returns — in Jersey City, NJ and on Long Island — listed under their real city names.
Verified prices — New York metro area
At $4.25–$4.75/gal, a full 20 lb tank (≈4.7 gal) costs about $19.98–$22.32 in propane. See the full 20 lb cost math.