What a gallon of refill propane actually costs: 121 verified prices
Propane refill pricing is one of the least transparent prices in everyday life: most stations post no per-gallon price online at all, and the ones that do are scattered across individual retailer pages. This site exists to collect them. As of the dataset's last review, it holds 121 verified per-gallon prices — every one traced to a named published source — across 25 metro areas in 19 states. This is what those verified numbers actually show.
The range: $3.10 to $5.80 a gallon
The cheapest verified refill price in the dataset is $3.10 per gallon in Portland, Oregon; the most expensive is $5.80 in Seattle, Washington. The median verified price is $4.10 a gallon and the mean is $4.08 — the middle of the market is tight even though the ends are far apart. That spread is not abstract. A standard 20 lb grill tank holds about 4.7 gallons when filled completely, so the difference between the cheapest and most expensive verified station is roughly $12.69 on a single tank fill — and the difference between a median station and the top of the range is still about $8. A $1-per-gallon spread, as the dataset's own notes put it, is worth roughly $4–$5 on one tank. Refill pricing rewards knowing your local number before you drive.
Why the ends are where they are
The dataset cannot prove causation, and this guide will not pretend otherwise. But the pattern at the extremes is worth describing accurately: the lowest verified prices cluster in Portland and San Antonio ($3.10–$3.50), while the highest cluster in Seattle ($5.77–$5.80) with Dallas also appearing at $5.00. Regional wholesale costs, state taxes and fees on motor fuel alternatives, and how much local competition a metro has all plausibly contribute; anyone who gives you a single confident reason for a metro's propane price is guessing. What is not a guess is the verification standard behind each number here: a price enters this dataset only with a named source and a check date, which is why the dataset is 121 prices deep rather than thousands — most stations simply do not publish, and unpublished prices are recorded as unknown rather than estimated.
What a full tank costs at the verified numbers
Multiply the per-gallon price by 4.7 and the range becomes concrete: a complete 20 lb fill costs about $14.57 at the cheapest verified station, about $19.27 at the median, and about $27.26 at the most expensive. Compare that against the exchange cage, where — as our refill vs. exchange guide works through — a "20 lb" exchange tank is typically filled to only 15 lb, roughly 3.5 gallons. The honest comparison is never the sticker; it is price divided by gallons actually received, and on that basis the verified refill numbers win at almost every point in the range.
How to use this where you live
- Find your metro's verified prices first on the price index. If your metro has several verified stations, the spread between them is your realistic saving for a short drive.
- If your station is listed as unknown, that means it does not publish a price — call and ask for the per-gallon rate, then do the 4.7 multiplication yourself before comparing with an exchange price.
- Watch for flat-fee pricing. Some stations charge per fill rather than per gallon; a flat fee is a good deal on an empty tank and a bad one on a half-full tank you are topping off. The per-gallon stations in this dataset never have that ambiguity.
- Report what you pay. The dataset grows through its report-a-price route; reader reports are labelled as reported, not verified, until they can be checked against a published source — the labelling discipline is the whole point of the site.
The figures in this guide are computed directly from the site's dataset of verified prices (121 records, each carrying its source), reviewed as a whole at the date shown in the dataset. Prices change; the station pages here carry the current records, and the verification standard — named source or "unknown" — does not change.